Nature-based Solutions - Fostering an Inclusive Approach to Technological Innovations by Marginalised Voices

Leaders at COP28 emphasised the pivotal role of nature-based solutions (NbS) in addressing the climate crisis, highlighting its significance in establishing resilient food systems and preserving oceans. However, these discussions often neglect examinations of institutional power dynamics embedded in these agendas, leading to NbS without true free, prior, and informed consent agreements with communities. Integration of technological innovation into these conversations poses a genuine risk of NbS perpetuating exploitative practices if not thoughtfully implemented.

In this brief, the authors address the risks associated with technology-enabled NbS solutions, such as epistemic injustice and the commodification of nature. In the context of low and middle-income countries in Asia, the absence of strong human rights and regulatory frameworks on land tenure has led to displacement and fueled discrimination and oppression of Indigenous Peoples and marginalised resource-dependent communities. While technological solutions are hailed as a panacea in the pursuit of NbS, these will play out in the context of digital divides, driving the concentration of power in the hands of a few actors.

By unpacking the dynamics at play, we urge a nuanced understanding of technology's potential within the context of preserving and restoring our natural environment. The brief presents a set of recommendations for policymakers, advocating for a cautious approach in investing in these solutions, informed by self-determination and reciprocity.